Constructive Criticism

Dear people who complain about musicians,

     If you’re going to complain about someone’s music say this: “God, I HATE THIS!” This means that a) you personally HATE THIS and b) this is your opinion. If you’re going to complain about someone’s music don’t say this: “Wow, this musician has literally no talent”, “Seriously? An ape could write this! Oh wait!”, or “Wow, the quality of music these days...” Now yes, some music is simpler that other music, some music can be more difficult to play, but just know that attacking a musician like that is like telling someone that the way they are existing isn't worth anyone’s time. Feel free to have your own opinions, but remember what an abstract thing “talent” is. There is no objective way to measure it and you cannot be RIGHT or WRONG about the quality of music.

     Music is Art. If you were going to be critical about a painting you’d probably say something constructive like this: “Wow, I feel like the focal point of this piece isn’t balanced with all this negative space over here” or “Hm. Ya’ know, I don’t think there’s enough contrast being applied with the colors, it just feels a little bland.” You wouldn’t say: “How could this possibly mean anything to anyone?”, “The message that this artist is trying to convey is completely worthless” or “This painter obviously has no talent.” What the heck.

     So hands (meaning words) off my music or anyone else’s, because someone, somewhere, right now, is dancing or crying or singing along to this song. And I mean obviously the lack of talent the singer/guitarist/songwriter/drummer has has invalidated the emotions of a thousand human beings, but just try to be nicer okay? Seriously though, keep opinions where opinions need to be kept, separate them from measurable facts, and don’t you try to tell me what you think about talent, because I hope it’s obvious that it’s really pissing me off.

Love you all,

Adair